Ladar range estimate with range rate compensation

ABSTRACT

A system and method for forming a range estimate for a target with a laser detection and ranging system. The system includes a laser transmitter and an array detector. The method includes: transmitting a plurality of laser pulses; for each transmitted laser pulse: detecting, with the array detector, a plurality of ladar return photons from the laser pulse, each detection producing an electrical pulse; identifying, for each of the electrical pulses, a time bin of a plurality of time bins corresponding to the laser pulse, within which the electrical pulse was produced; forming a one dimensional range histogram array having, for each of a subset of the plurality of bins, an element with a value equal to the number of electrical pulses produced in the array detector during a time interval corresponding to the bin; and forming an estimated range rate for the target.

FIELD

One or more aspects of embodiments according to the present inventionrelate to ladar, and more particularly to a system and method forgenerating high quality target characterizations using a ladar system.

BACKGROUND

A laser detection and ranging (ladar) system may be used to characterizea moving target, e.g., a target moving toward or away from the (ladar)system. The target may also be moving in a cross-range direction, and itmay be rotating. When the rate at which reflected photons are receivedfrom the target is modest, photon counts may be accumulated over arelatively long period of time to improve the signal to noise ratio ofthe characteristics of the target that are measured. The accumulating ofphoton counts over a relatively long period of time may, however, resultin blurring.

Thus, there is a need for an improved system and method for ladar signalprocessing.

SUMMARY

Aspects of embodiments of the present disclosure are directed toward asystem and method for ladar signal processing. A ladar system transmitsa sequence of laser pulses, and ladar return photons are detected, afterreflecting from a target, by a camera including a photodiode array,which generates electrical pulses when it absorbs photons. Counts ofelectrical pulses are accumulated in time bins. The camera generates aframe of data (the frame including a plurality of bins) for eachtransmitted laser pulse. The data in the frame may then be analyzedusing any of several different methods, to estimate the range and rangerate of the target, the cross-range velocity and angular velocity of thetarget, and to generate images of the target.

According to an embodiment of the present invention there is provided amethod for forming a range estimate for a target with a laser detectionand ranging system including a laser transmitter and an array detector,the method including: transmitting a plurality of laser pulses; for eachtransmitted laser pulse: detecting, with the array detector, a pluralityof ladar return photons from the laser pulse, each detection producingan electrical pulse; identifying, for each of the electrical pulses, atime bin of a plurality of time bins corresponding to the laser pulse,within which the electrical pulse was produced; forming a onedimensional range histogram array having, for each of a subset of theplurality of bins, an element with a value equal to the number ofelectrical pulses produced in the array detector during a time intervalcorresponding to the bin; forming an estimated range rate for thetarget; forming a two dimensional adjusted range versus frame arrayhaving a first plurality of columns, each of the first plurality ofcolumns being identified by a column number and including a portion ofone of the range histogram arrays, shifted in proportion to the productof the estimated range rate and the column number; summing the rows ofthe adjusted range versus frame array to form a collapsed histogram; andinferring the range from a location of a peak in the collapsedhistogram.

In one embodiment, the forming of an estimated range rate includes:forming a two dimensional range versus frame array having a secondplurality of columns, each of the second plurality of columnscorresponding to one of the range histogram arrays; forming a Radontransform of the range versus frame array to form a Radon transformarray, the Radon transform array being a two dimensional array having aplurality of rows each corresponding to a respective range rate and athird plurality of columns; summing the third plurality of columns ofthe element-wise square of the Radon transform array to form a collapsedRadon transform array; and calculating an initial estimated range rateas the range rate corresponding to a maximum value of the collapsedRadon transform array.

In one embodiment, the forming of an estimated range rate furtherincludes: setting a tentative range rate to be equal to the initialestimated range rate; iteratively adjusting the tentative range rate,through a sequence of values until a completion criterion is satisfied,and for each of the sequence of values: generating a two dimensionaltentative adjusted range versus frame array having a plurality rows anda fourth plurality of columns, each of the fourth plurality of columnscorresponding to one of the range histogram arrays, shifted inproportion to the product of the estimated range rate and the columnnumber; summing the rows of the tentative adjusted range versus framearray to form a tentative adjusted collapsed histogram; and calculatinga measure of sharpness for a peak in the tentative adjusted collapsedhistogram.

In one embodiment, the completion criterion is satisfied when themeasure of sharpness exceeds a threshold value.

In one embodiment, the calculating of a measure of sharpness includes:determining a maximum value of the tentative adjusted collapsedhistogram.

In one embodiment, the calculating of a measure of sharpness includes:fitting a Gaussian function to the tentative adjusted collapsedhistogram; and calculating a reciprocal of a width of the Gaussianfunction.

In one embodiment, the calculating of a measure of sharpness includes:calculating a ratio of: a numerical integral of the square of thetentative adjusted collapsed histogram and a numerical integral of thetentative adjusted collapsed histogram.

In one embodiment, the portion of one of the range histogram arrays is aportion centered on a bin corresponding to an initial estimate of arange to the target.

According to an embodiment of the present invention there is provided aladar system for forming a range estimate for a target, the systemincluding: a pulsed laser transmitter configured to transmit a sequenceof laser pulses; a camera including an array detector, the camera beingconfigured to: detect, for each laser pulse of the sequence of laserpulses, a plurality of ladar return photons from the laser pulse, eachdetection producing an electrical pulse; identify, for each of theelectrical pulses, a time bin of a plurality of time bins correspondingto the laser pulse, within which the electrical pulse was produced; aprocessing circuit, configured to: form a one dimensional rangehistogram array having, for each of a subset of the plurality of bins,an element with a value equal to the number of electrical pulsesproduced in the array detector during a time interval corresponding tothe bin; form an estimated range rate for the target; form a twodimensional adjusted range versus frame array having a first pluralityof columns, each of the first plurality of columns being identified by acolumn number and including a portion of one of the range histogramarrays, shifted in proportion to the product of the estimated range rateand the column number; sum the rows of the adjusted range versus framearray to form a collapsed histogram; and infer the range from a locationof a peak in the collapsed histogram.

In one embodiment, the processing circuit is configured to form anestimated range rate by: forming a two dimensional range versus framearray having a second plurality of columns, each of the second pluralityof columns corresponding to one of the range histogram arrays; forming aRadon transform of the range versus frame array to form a Radontransform array, the Radon transform array being a two dimensional arrayhaving a plurality of rows each corresponding to a respective range rateand a third plurality of columns; summing the third plurality of columnsof the element-wise square of the Radon transform array to form acollapsed Radon transform array; and calculating an initial estimatedrange rate as the range rate corresponding to a maximum value of thecollapsed Radon transform array.

In one embodiment, the processing circuit is configured to form anestimated range rate by: setting a tentative range rate to be equal tothe initial estimated range rate; iteratively adjusting the tentativerange rate, through a sequence of values until a completion criterion issatisfied, and for each of the sequence of values: generating a twodimensional tentative adjusted range versus frame array having aplurality rows and a fourth plurality of columns, each of the fourthplurality of columns corresponding to one of the range histogram arrays,shifted in proportion to the product of the estimated range rate and thecolumn number; summing the rows of the tentative adjusted range versusframe array to form a tentative adjusted collapsed histogram; andcalculating a measure of sharpness for a peak in the tentative adjustedcollapsed histogram.

In one embodiment, the completion criterion is satisfied when themeasure of sharpness exceeds a threshold value.

In one embodiment, the processing circuit is configured to calculate ameasure of sharpness by: determining a maximum value of the tentativeadjusted collapsed histogram.

In one embodiment, the processing circuit is configured to calculate ameasure of sharpness by: fitting a Gaussian function to the tentativeadjusted collapsed histogram; and calculating a reciprocal of a width ofthe Gaussian function.

In one embodiment, the processing circuit is configured to calculate ameasure of sharpness by: calculating a ratio of: a numerical integral ofthe square of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram and a numericalintegral of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.

In one embodiment, the portion of one of the range histogram arrays is aportion centered on a bin corresponding to an initial estimate of arange to the target.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Features, aspects, and embodiments are described in conjunction with theattached drawings, in which:

FIG. 1 is a schematic block diagram of a laser detection and ranging(ladar) system, according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 2A is a range versus frame image for a moving target, according toan embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 2B is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the range versus frameimage of FIG. 2A;

FIG. 2C is a range versus frame image for a moving target, according toan embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 2D is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the range versus frameimage of FIG. 2C;

FIG. 2E is an image of a Radon transform, according to an embodiment ofthe present invention;

FIG. 2F is an graph of sums of the columns of the element-wise square ofthe Radon transform of FIG. 2E;

FIG. 3A is an adjusted range versus frame image for a moving target,according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 3B is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the adjusted rangeversus frame image of FIG. 3A;

FIG. 3C is an adjusted range versus frame image for a moving target,according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 3D is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the adjusted rangeversus frame image of FIG. 3C;

FIG. 3E is an adjusted range versus frame image for a moving target,according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 3F is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the adjusted rangeversus frame image of FIG. 3E;

FIG. 3G is an adjusted range versus frame image for a moving target,according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 3H is a collapsed histogram corresponding to the adjusted rangeversus frame image of FIG. 3G;

FIG. 3I is a flow chart of a method for estimating a range rate andrange for a target, according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 4A is a set of three graphs of pulses and cosine fits, according toan embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 4B is a flow chart of a method for estimating a range rate,according to an embodiment of the present invention;

FIG. 5 is a block diagram of an iterative registration deblurringprocess, according to an embodiment of the present invention; and

FIG. 6 is an illustration of a chipping process, according to anembodiment of the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The detailed description set forth below in connection with the appendeddrawings is intended as a description of exemplary embodiments of asystem and method for operating a ladar provided in accordance with thepresent invention and is not intended to represent the only forms inwhich the present invention may be constructed or utilized. Thedescription sets forth the features of the present invention inconnection with the illustrated embodiments. It is to be understood,however, that the same or equivalent functions and structures may beaccomplished by different embodiments that are also intended to beencompassed within the spirit and scope of the invention. As denotedelsewhere herein, like element numbers are intended to indicate likeelements or features.

Referring to FIG. 1A, a ladar system may include a laser transmitter 100configured to transmit pulses at a pulse repetition frequency (e.g., 20kHz), and a camera 110 including imaging optics and a Geiger-modeavalanche photodiode array 120. The Geiger-mode avalanche photodiodearray 120 may detect ladar return photons that are transmitted in thepulses and reflected, from a target, into the camera 110. The photodiodearray 120 may have a frame rate equal to the pulse repetition frequency,and it may be synchronized with the laser transmitter 100, so that eachframe captured by the camera 110 includes only signal corresponding to asingle transmitted pulse. The reciprocal of the frame rate may bereferred to as the “frame period”.

During any frame acquisition interval (i.e., the period of time duringwhich the photodiode array 120 captures one frame of data), one or moreof the Geiger-mode avalanche photodiodes or “detector pixels” may detecta photon, and generate a corresponding electrical pulse, which may besensed by the readout integrated circuit (ROIC) 130. The ROIC 130 mayrecord the time at which the electrical pulse was received, to within acertain time resolution, e.g., 1.25 ns, corresponding, for example, to aperiod of a clock of the ROIC 130. In each frame, the detected photonsmay then be classified into time bins according to their arrival times,with, e.g., the photons detected at the beginning of the frame being inbin 0, the photons detected during a time interval beginning 1.25 nslater, and ending 2.5 ns later, being in bin 1, and so on.

The output from the ROIC 130 for each frame may be a 3-dimensionalarray, referred to herein as the “ROIC output array”, with two of thedimensions being pixel dimensions and the third dimension being binnumber. Each element of the array may be either a 1 (if a photon wasdetected by the corresponding pixel in the corresponding time bin) or a0 (e.g., if no photon was detected by the corresponding pixel in thecorresponding time bin). Because round trip travel time corresponds tothe range of the target, the time bins may also be referred to as rangebins. Each avalanche photodiode may be reset once per frame, at thebeginning of the frame, and each avalanche photodiode may have thecharacteristic that it will generate at most one electrical pulse perframe, i.e., after generating a pulse, the avalanche photodiode may bedisabled for the remainder of the frame, and incapable of generatinganother pulse, until it is reset at the beginning of the next frame.

The electrical pulses generated by the avalanche photodiode array 120may also include noise pulses, which may be caused by any of severalmechanisms, including photons received by the camera 110 that are notladar return photons, and dark noise (e.g., thermal noise) in theavalanche photodiode. The effects of this noise may be that (i) someelements of the ROIC output array may be 1 that in the absence of noisewould have been 0, as a result of a noise pulse, and (ii) some elementsof the ROIC output array may be 0 that in the absence of noise wouldhave been 1, as a result of a pixel receiving a ladar return photonafter having been disabled by a noise pulse produced earlier in the sameframe.

The Geiger-mode avalanche photodiode array 120 may also operate with arange gate, i.e., a signal that enables it only during a portion of aframe, e.g., a portion corresponding to an estimated target range. Theuse of the range gate may reduce the effect of noise pulses thatotherwise would be generated outside of the range gate time interval,e.g., well before the first ladar return photons from a given lasertransmitter pulse, or well after the last ladar return photons. The ROICoutput array may be sized accordingly. If, for example, the Geiger-modeavalanche photodiode array 120 has a size of 1024×1024 pixels, and ifthe length of the range gate is 5,000 bins, then the ROIC output arraymay have dimensions of 1024×1024×5000. Each 1024×1024 slice of the arraycorresponding to one time bin may be referred to herein as a bin sliceof the ROIC output array.

The ROIC output array may be subsequently processed, e.g., by aprocessing circuit 140. The subsequent processing may include, forexample, employing a “chipping” algorithm to discard bin slices of aROIC output array corresponding to bins that are too early or too lateto be likely to include any signals corresponding to a target ofinterest. The chipping algorithm may employ information in the ROICoutput array (or in a set of ROIC output arrays) and may set a chippingtime interval (outside of which signals are discarded) that issignificantly shorter than the range gate time interval, withoutdiscarding a significant amount of data corresponding to ladar returnphotons. The input to the chipping algorithm, for each frame, may be aone-dimensional array of sums over the bin-slices of the frame, referredto herein as the “range histogram” or “range histogram array” for theframe (and illustrated, for example, in FIG. 6); the output of thechipping algorithm may be referred to as a “chipped range histogram” or“chipped range histogram array”. The time interval corresponding to thedata that are not discarded may be referred to as a “chip” for theframe.

In some embodiments a set of ROIC output arrays, e.g., a setcorresponding to a contiguous set of frames, may be combined and furtherprocessed to improve the signal to noise ratio, or to obtain additionalinformation such as a target range rate. The set of ROIC output arraysmay be represented (conceptually, or in a memory of the processingcircuit 140) as a four-dimensional array, referred to herein as a frameset array, with, e.g., the first two dimensions being pixel coordinates,the third dimension being bin number, and the fourth dimension beingframe number. Chipping may be performed before the frame set array isformed.

Certain elements of the processing described herein as being performedin the processing circuit 140 may equally well be performed in the ROIC130, and vice versa. System design requirements including power and heatmanagement, and the bandwidths of interfaces between elements of thesystem, may influence where various processing operations are performed.

In some embodiments, the ladar system may be used to estimate the rangeto the target. In this case, each bin slice (or a portion of each binslice, corresponding to the approximate location of the image of thetarget on the photodiode array 120) from a chip may be summed, to form atwo-dimensional array referred to herein as a range versus frame array.Equivalently, the chipped range histograms may be stacked to form atwo-dimensional array in which each column is a chipped range histogramfor a respective frame. As used herein, the terms “row” and “column” asapplied to a two dimensional array refer to the two dimensions, with therow dimension being the first dimension and the column dimension beingthe second dimension, or with the column dimension being the firstdimension and the row dimension being the second dimension.

FIG. 2A shows, in a grayscale image, the result of this operation for aframe set array including 1000 frames, referred to herein as a rangeversus frame image. Each column of the image corresponds to one frame,and each row corresponds to a time bin (which corresponds to a rangebin, shown in the axis labels, and which may be used interchangeablywith time bin at least in reference to FIG. 2A). Each (rectangular)pixel of the image has a brightness proportional to the correspondingbin slice. A bright diagonal line is visible in the image, correspondingto a target the range of which changes from about 3698 m to about 3691 mover the time interval corresponding to 1000 frames (e.g., over 50 ms ifthe frame rate is 20 kHz). The thickness of the diagonal line maycorrespond to the “ladar range extent” of the target, i.e., it maycorrespond to the extent, in the range direction, of the portions of thetarget that produce ladar return photons (“self-shadowed” portions ofthe target, i.e., portions that face away from the ladar system, notcontributing to the thickness of the line).

The elements of a frame set array may also be summed along the framenumber dimension. The result may be an array of sums, referred to hereinas a “collapsed histogram”, the array including one sum for each binwithin the frame. The collapsed histogram may be graphed as a line graph(e.g., FIG. 2B), referred to herein as a “1D HRR image” (a onedimensional high range resolution image). It may also be displayed as ahistogram (e.g., FIG. 2D), or referred to as a “range profilehistogram”.

The line graph of FIG. 2B, being a sum of the range versus frame arrayalong the frame number dimension (e.g., a sum along the horizontaldimension of the array illustrated in FIG. 2A) shows a peak having awidth that is due in part to the ladar range extent of the target, andin part to the motion in the range direction of the target during thetime interval corresponding to the frame set. The width of the peak maylimit the accuracy of an estimate of the range of the target, that maybe performed using the array of sums illustrated in FIG. 2B.Accordingly, a method, described in further detail below, may be used toform an alternate sum, referred to herein as a “range rate adjustedcollapsed histogram”, which may have a peak that is not significantlybroadened by the motion of the target, and that may be used to generatea more precise target range estimate and an estimate of the target'srange rate.

The method includes forming an initial range rate estimate using a Radontransform, and then iteratively improving the estimate, e.g., using anextremum-finding method such as a gradient descent method, Brent'salgorithm, or a golden section search. In some embodiments the step offinding an initial range rate estimate from a Radon transform isomitted, and the initial range rate estimate is provided by anothermethod (e.g., an initial value of 0, or an externally supplied priorestimate, may be used). The (n-dimensional) Radon transform maps afunction on the n-dimensional coordinate space R^(n) into the set of itsintegrals over the hyperplanes of R^(n). For a two-dimensionalcoordinate space (e.g., a plane) the Radon transform maps an input imageinto an output image in which each point represents the integral over astraight line in the input image.

FIG. 2C shows data for a case in which the target is a vehicle movingwith a range rate of −200 m/s. The vehicle has two principal reflectivesurfaces, e.g., the front of the vehicle and the windshield of thevehicle. Accordingly, each frame (corresponding to a vertical slice, orcolumn, of the underlying range versus frame image of FIG. 2C) shows twocorresponding peaks. When the range versus frame image includes one ormore diagonal bright stripes (e.g., the two diagonal stripes of FIG.2C), the Radon transform may include one or more corresponding brightspots (represented for example as pixels with values that are largerthan the average of the pixels in the image), with each bright spotcorresponding to one of the one or more diagonal bright stripes.

FIG. 2E shows the Radon transform of the range versus frame arrayillustrated as the range versus frame image of FIG. 2C. The Radontransform in FIG. 2E has two bright spots, both at an angle coordinateof about 95 degrees, and with a difference in their respective offsetcoordinates corresponding to the separation between the two diagonalbright stripes of FIG. 2C. Accordingly, the Radon transform makes itpossible to estimate the range rate of each of the reflective surfacesof the vehicle, and its range. The Radon transform may be calculatednumerically as a discrete Radon transform, resulting in a 2-dimensionalarray (that may be displayed, for example as the image of FIG. 2E), eachelement of the array corresponding to a discrete combination of offsetand angle.

For example, FIG. 2F is a graph of a collapsed Radon transform array,which is the column-wise sums of the squares of the array elements(e.g., of the pixels) of the Radon transform, each sum corresponding toone of the discrete values of angle. Such a graph may show a peak at anangle corresponding to the range rate, e.g., at about 95 degrees in thecase of FIGS. 2E and 2F. This process may be expressed as follows:

${\theta_{init} = {\begin{matrix}{argmax} \\\theta\end{matrix}\Sigma_{x}{R\left( {\theta,x} \right)}^{2}}},$where θ and x are the angle and offset variables in the Radon transformR(θ, x) and θ_(init) is an angle that may be used to calculate aninitial estimate of the range rate, according to the following equation:v=½Fcτ tan(90−θ_(init))where F is the frame rate, c is the speed of light, τ is the duration ofa time bin, and the angle θ_(init) is in units of degrees (as, e.g., inFIG. 2E).

The range rate estimate obtained by finding the angle at which the peak(of the column sums of the Radon transform) occurs may then be refinedusing an iterative process. This process may involve repeatedlycalculating the range rate adjusted collapsed histogram, for variousvalues of the estimated range rate, and, calculating a measure of thesharpness of the peak in each such range rate adjusted collapsedhistogram, until a completion criterion is satisfied.

For each tentative range rate, an adjusted range versus frame array maybe formed by shifting each frame of the range versus frame array in therange bin direction by an amount equal, or approximately equal, to theproduct of the tentative range rate and the frame period. In forming therange rate adjusted range versus frame array, a rectangular array may beformed by padding columns with zeros, or cropping the chipped rangehistograms, as the chipped range histograms are shifted. If the productof the tentative range rate and the frame period is, for some frames,not an integer number of bins, then interpolation may be used togenerate an interpolated shifted frame, that approximates the effect ofshifting the frame by a non-integer number of bins, or each frame may beshifted by an integral number of bins, the number being the nearestinteger to the product of the tentative range rate and the frame period.The sum along the frame direction of the range versus frame array thenforms the range rate adjusted collapsed histogram.

FIG. 2A shows an image corresponding to the (unadjusted) range versusframe array for a target moving with a range rate of −150 m/s. Bydefinition, this is the same as the range rate adjusted range versusframe array, when the tentative range rate is 0 m/s. FIG. 2B shows agraph of the corresponding range rate adjusted collapsed histogram.

FIGS. 3A and 3B show the range rate adjusted range versus frame arrayand range rate adjusted collapsed histogram obtained, from the samerange versus frame array, respectively, using a tentative range rate of−100 m/s. The slope of the diagonal line in the range rate adjustedrange versus frame array of FIG. 3A is closer to horizontal relative tothat of FIG. 2A, as a result of adjusting for the tentative range rate,and the peak in the range rate adjusted collapsed histogram of FIG. 3Bis sharper than that of FIG. 2B because of the reduced blur.

FIGS. 3C and 3D show the range rate adjusted range versus frame arrayand range rate adjusted collapsed histogram obtained, from the samerange versus frame array, respectively, using a tentative range rate of−150 m/s. The slope of the diagonal line in the range rate adjustedrange versus frame array of FIG. 3C is essentially zero, as a result ofadjusting for the tentative range rate, and the peak in the range rateadjusted collapsed histogram of FIG. 3D is significantly sharper than inFIG. 3B and FIG. 2B because essentially all of the motion blur has beenremoved.

FIGS. 3E and 3F show the range rate adjusted range versus frame arrayand range rate adjusted collapsed histogram obtained, from the samerange versus frame array, respectively, using a tentative range rate of−175 m/s. The slope of the diagonal line in the range rate adjustedrange versus frame array of FIG. 3E is negative, as a result ofadjusting for the tentative range rate (which in this caseovercompensates for the range rate of the target), and the peak in therange rate adjusted collapsed histogram of FIG. 3F is broader than inFIG. 3D because the incorrect range rate fails to correct all of theblur.

From FIGS. 3A-3F it is apparent that, as evidenced by the sharpness ofthe peak of the adjusted collapsed histogram, −150 m/s is a betterestimate of the range rate of the target than −50 m/s or −175 m/s. Theprocess illustrated graphically in these figures may be readilyautomated by defining a sharpness metric for the peak in the adjustedcollapsed histogram and executing a maximum-finding algorithm (such as agradient descent algorithm, Brent's algorithm, or a golden sectionsearch) to find the tentative range rate for which the objectivefunction (e.g., the sharpness metric) is maximized. This tentative rangerate may then be used as the estimated target range rate, and thecorresponding adjusted collapsed histogram may be used to obtain ahigh-precision estimate of the target range (e.g., as the rangecorresponding to the peak value of the adjusted collapsed histogram).

The method described above may also reduce blurring due to range ratefor a target having, for example, two reflective portions as does (asmentioned above) the target for which a range versus frame array isillustrated in FIG. 2C, and a collapsed histogram is illustrated in FIG.2D. FIG. 2D shows a single broad peak in part because the blur resultingfrom range rate is sufficient to cause the peaks corresponding to thetwo reflective portions of the target to merge. When a suitableadjustment is made for the target range rate, the stripes of the rangerate adjusted range versus frame array become horizontal (as shown inFIG. 3G). These two horizontal stripes correspond to the two reflectiveportions of the target. Because of the adjustment made for the targetrange rate, the collapsed histogram (FIG. 3H) for the range rateadjusted range versus frame array shows two clearly resolved, sharppeaks, in contrast to the single broad peak in FIG. 2D. This improvementis analogous to the improvement obtained (as may be seen for example, bycomparing the respective peaks of FIG. 2B and FIG. 3D) when the targethas only one principal reflective portion.

FIG. 3I is a flowchart summarizing this process of range estimation. Inan act 320, a series of laser pulses is transmitted, and ladar returnphotons corresponding to the transmitted pulses are detected in an act325. From the detected photons (i.e., from the detection times of theelectrical pulses generated by detected photons) a plurality of rangehistograms is formed, in an act 330. In an act 335, a tentative targetrange rate is formed, e.g., using a Radon transform, as discussed indetail above. In some embodiments the initial tentative range rate isformed by another method, e.g., a constant value, such as 0 m/s, isused. In an act 340, an adjusted range versus frame array is formed byshifting each frame of the range versus frame array in the range bindirection by an amount equal, or approximately equal, to the product ofthe tentative range rate and the frame period. The rows of the adjustedrange versus frame array are summed, in an act 345, to form a range rateadjusted collapsed histogram, and a measure of sharpness is calculatedfrom a peak in the range rate adjusted collapsed histogram. Acts 335through 350 may be repeated, each time with a different value of thetentative range rate, until a completion criterion is satisfied. Thelocation of the peak in the range rate adjusted collapsed histogram maythen be used, in an act 355, to infer the range of the target. The finaltentative range rate may be used to infer the range rate of the target.In some embodiments the acts illustrated in FIG. 3I may not be performedsequentially but may, for example, overlap, e.g., the detection of ladarreturn photons corresponding to one laser pulse may occur concurrentlywith the transmission of subsequent laser pulses.

Various sharpness metrics may be used, including the peak value of theadjusted collapsed histogram, an integral of the adjusted collapsedhistogram over a small set of range bins (e.g., a number of binscorresponding to 5 m of range) centered on the peak, or the full widthat half maximum of the peak in the adjusted collapsed histogram. Otherpossible methods for calculating a sharpness metric include fitting thepeak in the adjusted collapsed histogram to a Gaussian function, andusing the reciprocal of the width of the Gaussian function as thesharpness metric, or calculating the standard deviation of the targetpoint cloud, or the ratio of (i) the integral of the square of theadjusted collapsed histogram to (ii) the integral of the adjustedcollapsed histogram. A “signal to noise ratio” or “SNR” sharpness metricmay be defined as the ratio of (i) the difference between (a) the meanof the adjusted collapsed histogram over a small set of range bins(e.g., a number of bins corresponding to 5 m of range) centered on thepeak (e.g., as estimated using a Gaussian fit) and (b) the mean of theadjusted collapsed histogram over a second set of range bins excludingthe peak (e.g., excluding a set of bins corresponding to 15 m of range,centered on the peak) and (ii) the standard deviation of the adjustedcollapsed histogram over the second set of range bins.

In another embodiment, the range rate of the target may be estimatedfrom the difference between the pulse repetition frequency and thereturn pulse arrival frequency. A target that is approaching the ladarsystem of FIG. 1, for example, will produce a sequence of return pulsesthat are separated by smaller intervals than the outgoing pulses,because each pulse travels a shorter round trip distance, from the lasertransmitter 100 to the target and back to the camera 110, than theprevious pulse. Written as an equation, this may be expressed asfollows:

${{\Delta\; f} \approx {\frac{2\overset{.}{r}}{c}F_{s}}},$where Δf is the difference between the pulse repetition frequency F_(s)and the return pulse arrival frequency, {dot over (r)} is the rangerate, and c is the speed of light.

Accordingly, the target range rate may be estimated from the returnpulses by estimating their frequency. Each frame set array includes aplurality of consecutive frames, each of which includes a plurality ofbins corresponding to the range gate. As mentioned above, the bin slicesmay be summed in each frame to form a respective array referred toherein as a “range histogram” for the frame. A chipping algorithm maythen be used (as described in further detail below) to discard from eachframe bins that are not likely to contain any signal reflected from thetarget, to form an array, for each frame, referred to herein as achipped range histogram. Each chipped range histogram may have a lengthequal to the number of bins not discarded in chipping, or it may have alength corresponding to the length of the range gate, with the remainingarray elements (corresponding to discarded bins) being set to zero.

A sparse one dimensional array, referred to herein as the “time series”,or “time series array” may then be formed by concatenating the chippedrange histograms with intervening arrays of zeros so that the arrayindex corresponds to arrival time at the camera 110. This array may bestored explicitly, e.g., in a sequence of memory locations within orcoupled to the processing circuit 140, or it may be stored in one ofvarious methods of storing sparse arrays that may use memory moreefficiently and that may result in more efficient computations. Forexample, only the chipped range histograms may be stored, each beingstored with an index value indicating where in the time series the firstelement of the chipped range histogram belongs.

The return pulse arrival frequency may then be estimated by theprocessing circuit 140 iteratively by adjusting a tentative frequencyand evaluating an objective function that measures how well asuperposition of a sine and a cosine fits the sparse one dimensionalarray. For each tentative frequency, two Fourier coefficients may becalculated by the processing circuit 140: (i) a cosine coefficient equalto the (numerical) integral of the product of the time series with acosine at the tentative frequency, and (ii) a sine coefficient equal tothe (numerical) integral of the product of the time series with a sineat the tentative frequency. The frequency of the return pulses may thenbe estimated by the processing circuit 140 by performing a numericalmaximization (e.g., using an extremum-finding method such as a gradientdescent method, Brent's algorithm, or a golden section search), usingthe tentative frequency as a variable and using as the objectivefunction the sum of the squares of the sine coefficient and the cosinecoefficient. A completion criterion may be met, for example, when thefractional improvement in the objective function over that of theprevious iteration is below a threshold, e.g., 0.0001. In someembodiments the threshold is adjustable and is selected depending onvarious conditions, and may be greater or smaller than 0.0001.

In some embodiments the chipped frames are concatenated without padding,resulting in a time-compressed time record. The apparent frequency maythen be determined by the chip size used. For example, FIG. 4A showsthree ladar return pulses (in three corresponding chipped time records,concatenated without padding), with (i) a superposition of a sine and acosine, both at the pulse repetition frequency (illustrated in curves410), and (ii) a cosine at the tentative frequency corresponding to thepulse repetition frequency shifted by an amount corresponding to a rangerate of −150 m/s (illustrated in curves 420). In the example of FIG. 4A,a 100 ns chip length was used, corresponding to a 10 MHz equivalent PRF.The frequency corresponding to the pulse repetition frequency shifted byan amount corresponding to a range rate of −150 m/s can be seen toprovide a better fit and accordingly will result in a larger value forthe sum of the squares of the sine coefficient and the cosinecoefficient.

FIG. 4B is a flowchart summarizing this method of range rate estimation.In an act 420, a series of laser pulses is transmitted, and aone-dimensional time series array may be formed, in an act 425, based onthe detection times of the electrical pulses generated by detectedphotons. The time series array may be padded with zeros so that eacharray element has an index proportional to time, or it may becompressed, i.e., formed by concatenating chipped time records withoutpadding. The time series may then be fit, in an act 430, with asuperposition of a sine and a cosine at a tentative frequency, and anobjective function, that may measure the goodness of fit, may becalculated, in an act 435. The fitting may involve multiplying the timeseries array by the cosine of the tentative frequency and integratingthe product numerically to calculate a cosine coefficient, andmultiplying the time series array by the sine of the tentative frequencyand integrating the product numerically to calculate a sine coefficient.The calculating of the objective function may involve calculating thesum of (i) the square of the cosine coefficient and (ii) the square ofsine coefficient. Acts 430 and 435 may be repeated with different valuesof the tentative frequency until a completion criterion is satisfied(e.g., when the objective function exceeds a threshold). The range ratemay then be inferred, as discussed in detail above, from the differencebetween the final value of the tentative frequency, and the pulserepetition rate, according to the following equation:

${\Delta\; f} \approx {\frac{2\overset{.}{r}}{c}{F_{s}.}}$

The method of this embodiment may exhibit better performance thanalternatives such as, e.g., computing a fast Fourier transform (FFT) ofthe time record, and finding the peak value of the magnitude of the FFT,because the FFT may have fixed resolution, whereas the resolution orprecision of the method of this embodiment may be limited only by thenumber of iterations used to refine the estimate, in theextremum-finding process.

In some embodiments, a target which is a rigid body may be moving in across-range direction, and a target may be rotating, in addition tomoving in the range direction as considered above. In such a situation,averaging together the data from a plurality of frames may result in ablurred image of the target, even if, before the averaging, anadjustment is made to each frame to compensate for the range rate of thetarget. Accordingly, in some embodiments, adjustments are made tocompensate for motion in one or more of the five additional degrees offreedom (in addition to range) in which the target may move. Thesedegrees of freedom include two translational degrees of freedom inrespective cross-range range directions, and three rotational degrees offreedom. As used herein, the “pose” of the target refers to asix-dimensional quantity defining the position and attitude of thetarget.

In one embodiment, an input to a method for motion compensation is aframe set array, corresponding to an interval of time during which thepose of the target may have changed enough that straight averaging ofthe frames would result in significant blurring.

Referring to FIG. 5, a frame set array may be formed from a plurality ofROIC output arrays each of which may first be reduced using a chippingprocess 605. Each frame of the frame set array may be converted to a“Level 1” three dimensional (3D) point cloud (identified as “L1” in FIG.5), in which each point represents a pulse generated by the photodiodearray 120, the cross-range coordinates of the point being proportionalto the coordinates on the photodiode array 120 of the pixel thatgenerated the pulse, and the range coordinate being proportional to theround-trip travel time (i.e., the time between the emission of the laserpulse corresponding to the frame, and the generation of the pulse).

The frames may be divided or split, in a step 610, into N groups(identified in FIG. 5 as G₁, G₂ . . . G_(N)), with each group includinga contiguous subset of the frames. For example, if the frame set arrayincludes 1000 frames, the frames may be grouped into 50 groups of 20frames each, with the first group including, for example, the first 20frames in the frame set array, the second group including the 21^(st)through 40^(th) frames, and so on. The number of frames in each groupmay be selected based on the competing advantages of achievingimprovements in signal to noise through averaging (which is betterachieved with a larger group) and of minimizing motion blur within thegroup (which is better achieved with a smaller group).

Within each group G₁, G₂ . . . G_(N), coincidence processing (CP) may beemployed to suppress noise. Each point cloud may be divided into threedimensional regions (e.g., regions each having the shape of arectangular parallelepiped or box, or of a cube) referred to herein asvoxels. Each voxel may consist for example of a cube having a sidelength of 4 pixels (in the cross range dimensions, and a similar size,in meters, in the range dimension). The number of pulses in each voxelin the frame may be counted, and, if it falls below a threshold, all ofthe array elements within the voxel may be set to zero for each frame inthe group. This processing may result in suppressing noise more thansignal, because noise may be less likely to produce pulses at the same(or nearly the same) point in successive frames than ladar returnphotons. In some embodiments, a coincidence processing method employinga different algorithm is used.

An average point cloud may be formed for each of the groups of framesafter coincidence processing (identified in FIG. 5 as G₁′, G₂′ . . .G_(N)′) and the average point clouds G₁′, G₂′ . . . G_(N)′ may then bepairwise registered using a registration process 620, each pairconsisting of the first group, and one of the remaining groups, with,e.g., the N^(th) pair consisting of the G₁′ and G_(N)′. The symbols G₁,G₂ . . . G_(N) and G₁′, G₂′ . . . G_(N)′ are used herein to refer to thegroups of frames, or to the corresponding average point clouds. Aniterative closest point (ICP) algorithm may be used as the registrationprocess, for example. The result of the registration process may be a6-dimensional transformation (or “Offset” in FIG. 5) that approximatelytransforms the point cloud of the first group of each pair of groups(the “first point cloud”) to the point cloud of the second group of eachpair of groups (the “second point cloud”). Each such transformation may,for example, be represented as (i) a vector representing thetranslational portion of the transformation and (ii) a set of rotationangles (e.g., three Euler angles) or a quaternion representing therotational portion of the transformation. Range rate compensation may beperformed separately, e.g., using one of the methods described above,with the result that the input frame set array may be the output of arange rate compensation process, and that the range component of thetransformation may be relatively small.

The registration process may, as mentioned above, involve performing anICP algorithm, which may involve the steps of (i) for each point in thefirst point cloud, finding the closest point in the second point cloud,(ii) estimating the transformation (i.e., the combination of rotationand translation) that best aligns (as assessed by a mean squared errorcost function) each point in the first point cloud to its match (foundin the previous step) in the second point cloud, (iii) transforming thepoints of the first point cloud using the estimated transformation, and(iv) repeating steps (i) through (iii), until a first completioncriterion is satisfied (e.g., until the incremental improvement in thecost function falls below a threshold, or until the match of each pointin the first point cloud is the same as it was during the precedingiteration).

From each transformation, an estimated 6-dimensional velocity (includinga translational velocity and a rotational, or angular, velocity) may becalculated by dividing the transformation by the time interval betweenthe centers of the two groups of any of the pairs of groups.

After the registration process is completed, an average 6-dimensionalvelocity (including a translational velocity and a rotational, orangular, velocity) may be calculated for each group as the average of(i) the velocity corresponding to the transformation between thepreceding group and the group, and (ii) the velocity corresponding tothe transformation between the group and the subsequent group. For thefirst group the average velocity may be the velocity corresponding tothe transformation between the group and the subsequent (i.e., second)group, and for the last group the average velocity may be the velocitycorresponding to the transformation between the preceding group (i.e.,the second-last group) and the group. Each of the groups of point clouds(corresponding to the groups of frames) may be then be deblurred, in adeblurring operation 635, by transforming each point cloud after thefirst point cloud in the group with a transformation calculated to beproportional to (e.g., equal to a negative constant times) the productof the average velocity for the group and the time interval between thepoint cloud and the first point cloud in the group. Each point cloud inthe group of point clouds may be numbered, in consecutive order, with anindex, the first point cloud having index 0, the second point cloudhaving index 1, and so forth; in this case the time interval between thepoint cloud and the first point cloud in the group may be proportionalto the index of the point cloud within the group of point clouds. Theprocess of deblurring each group and registering the groups pairwise maybe repeated. After each iteration the blurring due to object motion maybe further reduced as the accuracy of the velocity estimates improves,and the accuracy of the velocity estimates may improve as a result ofthe reduced blurring of the point clouds used to obtain them. Theiterations may be repeated until a second completion criterion issatisfied (e.g., when a measure of the change in the transformationsfrom the previous iteration is less than a threshold value). The pointclouds may then all be merged, in an operation 625, into a single “Level2” (or “L2”) point cloud. This merging may be accomplished, for example,by first transforming (in a “Shift” operation 630) each deblurred pointcloud, with, for example the k^(th) point cloud (i.e., G_(k)′) beingtransformed with a transformation that is the inverse of thetransformation corresponding to the estimated change in attitude fromthe first point cloud G₁′ to the k^(th) point cloud. A merged pointcloud, consisting of all of the points of the transformed deblurredpoint clouds, may then be formed.

Various methods may be used to perform the chipping operation mentionedabove (e.g., the chipping operation 605 of FIG. 5, and the chippingoperation that may be used to form chipped range histograms from rangehistograms, resulting, e.g., in the range versus frame image of FIG.2A). A chipping algorithm may be an algorithm that selects a portion(e.g., a contiguous subset of the elements) of a range histogram, theportion being centered on an element corresponding to an initialestimate of a range to the target.

In some embodiments, the chipping operation includes forming apreliminary range estimate, and selecting a set of bins centered on thepreliminary range estimate. In one embodiment, a coarse range histogrammay be formed, by summing the elements of range histograms withinrespective groups whose extent corresponds to the expected target sizeand motion. The coarse range histogram may be cropped and sharpened,e.g., with a finite impulse response filter having coefficients of[−0.5, 1, −0.5]. A peak may be found in the sharpened histogram. Asubset of the original range histogram may then be selected, centered onthe peak found using the coarse range histogram. Referring to FIG. 6,this range histogram may have a peak (i.e., a maximum value in a firstbin) 650. A relatively small test interval, including, e.g., 3 bins, maybe set initially to be centered on the peak bin; the first test intervalis labeled “Test₀” in FIG. 6. A left background interval may be definedto be all of the bins to the left of the test interval (e.g., initiallybeing the interval “Background₀). The test interval may then beprogressively moved to the left; once the peak bin is no longer withinthe test interval, a signal interval, “Signal₇” for example, may bedefined to include the peak bin and the bins, if any, to the right ofthe test interval (e.g., “Test₇”) and to the left of the peak bin. Anobjective function may be defined to be the ratio of (i) the differencebetween the mean of the bins in the test interval and the mean of thebins in the background interval, and (ii) the mean of the bins in thesignal interval. The test interval may then be progressively moved tothe left until the value of the objective function falls below athreshold, e.g., 0.05. This may be written as follows:(mean(Testn)−mean(Backgroundn))/mean(signaln)<0.05

where Testn (or Test_(n)) is a contiguous set of k bins, k being aninteger greater than 1, Signaln (or Signal_(n)) is a contiguous set ofbins beginning immediately to the right of Testn and extending to a peakbin having the largest value in the histogram array, Backgroundn (orBackground_(n)) is a contiguous set of bins beginning immediately to theleft of Testn and extending to the left edge of the range histogramarray, and the mean( ) function refers to an average of a set of binsthat is the argument of the function.

One of the bins of the test interval (e.g., the left-most bin) may thenbe used as the left boundary of the portion of the frame not discardedby the chipping algorithm. An analogous process may be used to find theright boundary.

In another embodiment, chipping may be performed, if an initial valuefor the expected ladar range extent of the target is available, asfollows. The range bin with the largest number of counts may be found,and then all of the range bins having at least 50% of this largestnumber of counts may be identified. All range bins farther than expectedtarget size (i.e., half of the expected ladar range extent of thetarget) away from the peak range bin may be eliminated, and a full widthat half maximum (FWHM) may be calculated as the extent of the remainingrange bins. A background may be defined as all range bins that are morethan four times the FWHM away from the peak range bin, and thebackground offset and noise may be defined as the mean and standarddeviation of the background, respectively. The SNR of each range bin maybe calculated as (y−offset)/noise where y is the number of counts in therange bin. The target size may be defined as the extent of range binswith SNR greater than 5.0, and the target range may be defined as theweighted average (by counts per bin) of the target range bins. Thechipping algorithm may then discard (e.g., set to zero) all bins thatare more distant from the bin at the target range than one half of thetarget size.

In some embodiments, background subtraction may be performed as apreliminary step before performing chipping, e.g., as described above. Arange histogram may be fitted to an exponential background model (inwhich the background is modeled as being proportional to exp(a+br)). Thefit may be performed via a linear regression to the logarithm of therange histogram. This exponential model describes range distribution ofGeiger mode pulses in the presence of constant background flux and takesinto account the gradual loss of sensitivity during each frame as pixelsare disabled by noise pulses. The modeled background may be subtractedfrom the range histogram.

In another embodiment, a three-dimensional chipping algorithm may beused to eliminate signal that is too distant from the center of thetarget in the range direction or in either of the cross-range directionsto correspond to reflections from the target, as follows. An uncertaintyvolume may be defined by a bounding box defined by minimum and maximumazimuth, elevation, and range values in which target may reside (givenprior knowledge about the target). Dimensions may then be defined foreach of a plurality of “macrovoxels”; these dimensions may be azimuth,elevation, and range extents corresponding to nominal target size,enlarged by the maximum expected motion during the collection time. Theuncertainty volume may then be divided into a dense, non-overlapping,three dimensional grid of macrovoxels. An accumulation array may beinitialized, with one array element for each macrovoxel. For eachdetection in the collected data, it may be determined which (if any)macrovoxel it falls into, and, accordingly, a count may be accumulatedfor each macrovoxel. Any detections that are outside the uncertaintyvolume may be ignored. The macrovoxel with the most counts may then befound. Optionally, the algorithm may also check that this count exceedsa threshold; otherwise, it may declare that “no target” was found. Themacrovoxel with the most counts may then be used as the threedimensional “chip”, and further processing may be restricted to thedetections within this chip.

Embodiments of the present invention may be used to estimate the rangeand range rate of a target, to estimate the cross-range velocity andangular velocity of the target, and to generate images of the target.The results may be used for various purposes, such as displaying theresults, graphs of the results, or resulting images on a display for theuse of an operator, or to identify the target using targetidentification algorithms, or to rendezvous with the target or interceptthe target.

The term “processing circuit” is used herein to include any combinationof hardware, firmware, and software, employed to process data or digitalsignals. Processing circuit hardware may include, for example,application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), general purpose orspecial purpose central processing units (CPUs), digital signalprocessors (DSPs), graphics processing units (GPUs), and programmablelogic devices such as field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs). In aprocessing circuit, as used herein, each function is performed either byhardware configured, i.e., hard-wired, to perform that function, or bymore general purpose hardware, such as a CPU, configured to executeinstructions stored in a non-transitory storage medium. A processingcircuit may be fabricated on a single printed wiring board (PWB) ordistributed over several interconnected PWBs. A processing circuit maycontain other processing circuits; for example a processing circuit mayinclude two processing circuits, an FPGA and a CPU, interconnected on aPWB.

Although limited embodiments of a system and method for operating aladar have been specifically described and illustrated herein, manymodifications and variations will be apparent to those skilled in theart. Accordingly, it is to be understood that a system and method foroperating a ladar employed according to principles of this invention maybe embodied other than as specifically described herein. The inventionis also defined in the following claims, and equivalents thereof.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method for forming a range estimate for atarget with a laser detection and ranging system comprising a lasertransmitter and an array detector, the method comprising: transmitting aplurality of laser pulses; for each transmitted laser pulse: detecting,with the array detector, a plurality of ladar return photons from thelaser pulse, each detection producing an electrical pulse; identifying,for each of the electrical pulses, a time bin of a plurality of timebins corresponding to the laser pulse, within which the electrical pulsewas produced; and forming a one dimensional range histogram array of aplurality of range histogram arrays having, for each of a subset of theplurality of time bins, an element with a value equal to a number ofelectrical pulses produced in the array detector during a time intervalcorresponding to the time bin; forming an estimated range rate for thetarget; forming a two dimensional adjusted range versus frame arrayhaving a first plurality of columns, each of the first plurality ofcolumns being identified by a column number and including a portion ofone of the range histogram arrays, shifted in proportion to a product ofthe estimated range rate and the column number; summing rows of the twodimensional adjusted range versus frame array to form a collapsedhistogram; and determining the range from a location of a peak in thecollapsed histogram, wherein the forming of an estimated range ratecomprises: forming a two dimensional range versus frame array having asecond plurality of columns, each of the second plurality of columnscorresponding to one of the range histogram arrays; forming a Radontransform of the range versus frame array to form a Radon transformarray, the Radon transform array being a two dimensional array having aplurality of rows each corresponding to a respective range rate and athird plurality of columns; summing the third plurality of columns ofelement-wise square of the Radon transform array to form a collapsedRadon transform array; and calculating an initial estimated range rateas a range rate corresponding to a maximum value of the collapsed Radontransform array.
 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the forming of anestimated range rate further comprises: setting a tentative range rateto be equal to the initial estimated range rate; iteratively adjustingthe tentative range rate, through a sequence of values until acompletion criterion is satisfied, and for each of the sequence ofvalues: generating a two dimensional tentative adjusted range versusframe array having a plurality rows and a fourth plurality of columns,each of the fourth plurality of columns corresponding to one of therange histogram arrays, shifted in proportion to the product of theestimated range rate and the column number; summing the rows of thetentative adjusted range versus frame array to form a tentative adjustedcollapsed histogram; and calculating a measure of sharpness for a peakin the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.
 3. The method of claim 2,wherein the completion criterion is satisfied when the measure ofsharpness exceeds a threshold value.
 4. The method of claim 2, whereinthe calculating of a measure of sharpness comprises: determining amaximum value of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.
 5. Themethod of claim 2, wherein the calculating of a measure of sharpnesscomprises: fitting a Gaussian function to the tentative adjustedcollapsed histogram; and calculating a reciprocal of a width of theGaussian function.
 6. The method of claim 2, wherein the calculating ofa measure of sharpness comprises: calculating a ratio of: a numericalintegral of a square of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram and anumerical integral of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.
 7. Themethod of claim 2, wherein the portion of one of the range histogramarrays is a portion centered on a bin corresponding to an initialestimate of a range to the target.
 8. A ladar system for forming a rangeestimate for a target, the ladar system comprising: a pulsed lasertransmitter configured to transmit a sequence of laser pulses; a cameracomprising an array detector, the camera being configured to: detect,for each laser pulse of the sequence of laser pulses, a plurality ofladar return photons from the laser pulse, each detection producing anelectrical pulse; and identify, for each of the electrical pulses, atime bin of a plurality of time bins corresponding to the laser pulse,within which the electrical pulse was produced; and a processingcircuit, configured to: form a one dimensional range histogram array ofa plurality of range histogram arrays having, for each of a subset ofthe plurality of time bins, an element with a value equal to a number ofelectrical pulses produced in the array detector during a time intervalcorresponding to the time bin; form an estimated range rate for thetarget; form a two dimensional adjusted range versus frame array havinga first plurality of columns, each of the first plurality of columnsbeing identified by a column number and including a portion of one ofthe range histogram arrays, shifted in proportion to a product of theestimated range rate and the column number; sum rows of the twodimensional adjusted range versus frame array to form a collapsedhistogram; and determine a range from a location of a peak in thecollapsed histogram, wherein the processing circuit is configured toform an estimated range rate by: forming a two dimensional range versusframe array having a second plurality of columns, each of the secondplurality of columns corresponding to one of the range histogram arrays;forming a Radon transform of the range versus frame array to form aRadon transform array, the Radon transform array being a two dimensionalarray having a plurality of rows each corresponding to a respectiverange rate and a third plurality of columns; summing the third pluralityof columns of element-wise square of the Radon transform array to form acollapsed Radon transform array; and calculating an initial estimatedrange rate as a range rate corresponding to a maximum value of thecollapsed Radon transform array.
 9. The ladar system of claim 8, whereinthe processing circuit is configured to form an estimated range rate by:setting a tentative range rate to be equal to the initial estimatedrange rate; iteratively adjusting the tentative range rate, through asequence of values until a completion criterion is satisfied, and foreach of the sequence of values: generating a two dimensional tentativeadjusted range versus frame array having a plurality rows and a fourthplurality of columns, each of the fourth plurality of columnscorresponding to one of the range histogram arrays, shifted inproportion to the product of the estimated range rate and the columnnumber; summing the rows of the tentative adjusted range versus framearray to form a tentative adjusted collapsed histogram; and calculatinga measure of sharpness for a peak in the tentative adjusted collapsedhistogram.
 10. The ladar system of claim 9, wherein the completioncriterion is satisfied when the measure of sharpness exceeds a thresholdvalue.
 11. The ladar system of claim 9, wherein the processing circuitis configured to calculate a measure of sharpness by: determining amaximum value of the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.
 12. Theladar system of claim 9, wherein the processing circuit is configured tocalculate a measure of sharpness by: fitting a Gaussian function to thetentative adjusted collapsed histogram; and calculating a reciprocal ofa width of the Gaussian function.
 13. The ladar system of claim 9,wherein the processing circuit is configured to calculate a measure ofsharpness by: calculating a ratio of: a numerical integral of a squareof the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram and a numerical integralof the tentative adjusted collapsed histogram.
 14. The ladar system ofclaim 9, wherein the portion of one of the range histogram arrays is aportion centered on a bin corresponding to an initial estimate of arange to the target.